Class notes for 5/4, part 1: more on expected value

The expected value of a two outcome game (win or lose) can be written as EV= p*(profit+risk)/risk. By dividing by risk, the game's expected value can be thought of as a percentage of money returned to you on average every time you play. Again, this is an average, so the average outcome doesn't have to be achieved. In many games, it never is. Expected value is really about the long run.

Flipping a fair coin, if you call "heads" every time, you should win about 50% of the time, and so EV = .5(1+1)/1 = 100%, so calling heads is a way to make this a fair game with a fair coin.

If you mix up your calls, it's also a fair game.

If you go with "rock" every time in rock/papers/scissors, your opponent will catch on soon enough and go with "paper" every time, and you will lose money in the long run.

Rock/scissors/paper is a fair game only if you can mix up your calls using some random method, or at least a method hard for your opponent to determine. The best method is 1/3 rock, 1/3 scissors and 1/3 paper, and the expected value is 100%, or that you will neither lose nor win, but break even.

Let's go back to roulette. We saw that playing a single number or playing either black or red produce the same expected value for the player.

Single number for player
p = 1/38
profit = 35
risk = 1
EV = 1/38*(35+1)/1 = 36/38 ~= 94.7%

Red (or Black) for player
p = 18/38
profit = 1
risk = 1
EV = 18/38*(1+1)/1 = 36/38 ~= 94.7%

For the casino, the probability of winning is 1 minus the probability for the player. The risk and profit numbers are switched from the players' values.

Single number for casino
p = 37/38
profit = 1
risk = 35
EV = 37/38*(35+1)/35 = (36*37)/(35*38) ~= 100.15%

Red (or Black) for player
p = 20/38
profit = 1
risk = 1
EV = 20/38*(1+1)/1 = 40/38 ~= 105.3%

When profit = risk, which is the same as saying the classic parimutuel odds are 1:1 or the modern parimutuel odds are +100 (which is the same as -100, though rarely written that way), the average of the two expected values will be 100%. You expect to lose about 5.3 cents every game and the casino expects to win about 5.3 cents.

When profit does not equal risk, we get different percentage advantages and disadvantages. Because the casino must risk 35 bets and the player only 1 bet when the player picks a single number at roulette, the expected value for the casino is still positive, but relatively small at .15 of a cent per game. In reality, the casino rarely spins the wheel with only one bettor playing, so the casino is not truly risking only its own money on a single spin, but can use the losses of some players to help offset any possible winner. Even if that weren't the case, a game with an expected value greater than 100% means a winner in the long run, and that is the business model the casino operate on, and very successfully as anyone can see.